64 Comments
User's avatar
LT Levine's avatar

This is brilliant. First, you named your Substack "Once-in-a-Species," referring of course to Bitcoin. I'm sure most people thought you were being a little hyperbolic.

But then, years later, you came up with a novel set of insights to fully justify it. How sweet is that?!

Jesse Myers's avatar

Thank you LT! When I chose the name for my Substack, I knew I would write this piece. This was a topic I touched on in my 2021 podcast with Preston Pysh - was already bouncing around in my head by then.

When I finally sat down to do the research a few months ago, the rabbit hole opened up much deeper than I expected. And I found myself breaking new ground.

Quite sweet to make good on that hyperbolic name!

Joe's avatar

Time for part 2 with Preston!

Dave's avatar

Lots of work went into this Jesse and I appreciate you sharing it. Very plausible and captivating.

Not only do we appreciate scarcity, we penalize fraud, plagiarism and counterfeiting because we are programmed against it.

So not only have you explained our fascination with Bitcoin, you have explained bitcoiner’s aversion to altcoins!! Great stuff

Jesse Myers's avatar

That's a very interesting second-order implication that I had not considered, and I think you're spot on.

Since we deeply appreciate and value scarcity, we naturally also revile frauds masquerading as scarce. I certainly hadn't contemplated how this theory ties in to Bitcoiners' aversion to altcoins, but it absolutely ties in!

Joe's avatar

haha - great points!

Justin Grigonis's avatar

I love how your thesis explains multiple things that have been misunderstood or simply gone unresolved... how we grew beyond the Dunbar number and supported larger population densities (crowding out Neanderthals), what truly defines our species and makes us human - namely the propensity to appreciate and collect scarce things, which organically leads to monetary systems, which explains the true function of ancient shell bead jewelry.... and it all dovetails nicely with the archeological and genetic record. Wow. Whenever a single hypothesis explains so many different things it's usually an indication that you're onto something. Well done!

Jesse Myers's avatar

Thank you, Justin! You grasped everything I was hoping to convey and thread together.

I stuck my neck out on Twitter and said that this piece was groundbreaking. A tall order.

But I knew what I was looking at, and this thesis resolved so many loose ends about the reasons for and timeline of humanity's success.

I think you're dead right that a hypothesis that explains many different things tends to mean something. Here's hoping that this stands the test of time! Thank you for reading, and for your generous review!

Toddy Stewart's avatar

This is fascinating. But I'm not sure if I totally follow the logic. Humans beat out neanderthals et al because we could think in abstractions. Which meant we could make money and sustain larger populations and a kind of societal interconnectivity. Larger societal grouping meant more power and safety on a number of levels. This all tracks, it all makes sense. Great. But you stop there. You ascribe it all to money. Whereas the abstraction of money that can cause these societal bonds that create greater population bases and power is an abstraction. An abstraction to a tool. Wouldn't money then just be one of the many tools that abstraction can create to build stronger societal bonds and do all the things? I may be missing a really important specific step here. There's something missing about sufficiency and necessity somewhere. Societal cohesion might be brought about by money and much else that might come from abstraction, couldn't it?

Jesse Myers's avatar

Yes, that is a very fair line of reasoning.

I certainly agree that money would be one several advantages to having a greater capacity for abstract thought, and that these other advantages undoubtedly played a role as well.

Partly, I didn't want to overcomplicate the flow of my narrative - it already demands a lot of the reader by joining together several different fields of study. But mainly, when I thought about how "greater abstract thought" would directly translate into a greater species-level advantage, nothing stands out as a concrete, tangible advantage that fits the facts, except money.

I think the section on Dunbar's number is the part that speaks to this, more than the rest, because it provides a tangible answer to how "greater abstract thought" translates to civilization-level behavior. The alternative would be lacking - for example, "greater abstract thought" allows people to negotiate alliances and understand the advantages of tribal coordination for mutual strength... plausible, but more wishy washy.

Toddy Stewart's avatar

Right. this makes sense to cut to the chase for this purpose. And yet the exchange of "money" (rarefied goods?) might suppose the market place and the market place might suppose standardization and standardization might suppose some bureaucracy which might suppose some kind of existential hierarchy only available to conceptual planners? I'm not sure that's the exact right vocabulary. But what role might organized religion play in this... even to the point of a deified ruler or the authority of the soothsayer/shaman/priest alluding to greater powers of accountability beyond animism and simple sustenance. Stuff like that. Higher level implementation that proceeds to cohesion and solidarity across wider and more disparate populations. However, the original point of this higher level abstraction that you've laid out is the key. Very good.

Elli's avatar

My mind followed this thread another direction as well. The affinity for abstract thought could also lead to well thought out plans to eliminate a competitive subspecies.

Joe's avatar

Makes sense. Worth exploring that further.

John Kramer's avatar

As a person who studies the brain for a living (with undergraduate degree in history) the intersection of anthropology and neuroscience makes logical sense here, and Jesse you nailed it! This is likely unknowable, but it would be interesting to look at gold in the historical record to see if it too had wild fluctuations in value during the early days of its own store of value

Jesse Myers's avatar

Thank you John! Glad it resonated with your brain and history studies.

And agree, that would be fascinating to see. Saifedean does a good job of charting the fluctuating value of monetary metals in antiquity, though I don't think there's any data on it from the pre-writing days of gold's emergence ~6,000 BP.

Joe's avatar

Very fascinating and thorough! Are you going to get this peer-reviewed and published?? That would be awesome!

Nick Szabo was such an important contributor to our understanding of money and the development of electronic cash with his "bit gold" design that was a large basis of the design of Bitcoin.

Clearly the scarcity of Bitcoin is a massive advantage over all other forms of money available today. Szabo had this idea of scarcity of collectibles like shells and jewelry in mind. Have you made him aware of this article? I bet he'd enjoy it. As he put it, items that make good money are scarce due to their "unforgeable costliness."

This is a fantastic contribution to the understanding of money and the importance of Bitcoin. Thanks!!

Jesse Myers's avatar

Thank you, Joe! Szabo's "Shelling Out" was absolutely seminal for me, and I wanted to do this piece justice as something of a follow-up that builds on that work.

I will look into submitting it to some Anthropology magazines. Might have to remove the final section for palatability for those outlets. But I expect there will still be muted interest, since I'm an outsider and less than kind to mainstream Anthropology. I do need to defend against someone copying my hypothesis and running with it tho, so hopefully I can get this piece to as many astute thinkers as possible.

Joe's avatar

I just watched an interview of Natalie Smolenski (Joe Burnett, Unchained: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDpql1Do2W4) and found out that she's an anthropologist bitcoiner. Have you discussed this with her? I'm sure she would be interested in this.

Jesse Myers's avatar

I would welcome her thoughts! Please do send it to her, it's always much more persuasive if it's a third-party recommendation to read a piece :)

Annah's avatar

Jesse I'm also going to send this to an Anthropologist I met last month at a Bitcoin Meetup in Australia. He is doing his PhD on the role of cryptocurrencies.

Keith's avatar

Awesome article, Jesse!! Thank you.

Paul Berry's avatar

Hi Jesse

Thank you not just for this, but for sharing your understandings generally. You are plainly very bright but also with a kind heart which is a powerful mix for good.

Jesse Myers's avatar

Thank you, Paul! That is a very kind and much appreciated note. Here's hoping this piece can reach many on their journeys to understanding Bitcoin

Brian's avatar

Interesting. What you've just done is illustrate that this theory/hypothesis opens up whole new fields of research.

And those new avenues of research may well end up describing or articulating the subsequent development of civilization -- religion, authority, heirarchy, monumental construction, abstract communication (writing), money -- a development that eluded other human subspecies.

Jesse Myers's avatar

It would be incredible if this hypothesis opens up new lines of academic inquiry and helps shape Anthropology's understanding of early humanity in some way.

I expect that mainstream Anthropology will be resistant to an outsider's answer, but I think Bitcoin's educational canon shapes the future, so maybe in time it will.

Insult To Injury's avatar

Great stuff. A thoughtful and insightful synthesis of some of my favourite things!

David Thornton's avatar

I find this article fascinating but I have a question that seems extremely relevant yet unaddressed: All of the money modalities going back 142,000 years have been PHYSICAL in nature. All of them. And it is the physically rare nature of these items that have made them scarce AND desirable to our physical senses, which then drives them through the process to eventually be considered money. Bitcoin lacks any physical presence in our world. Humans can't physically touch it, desire it, or accumulate it in a physical "stack." One of the reasons gold (and silver to a lesser degree) have been so successful in it's long run as a hard money standard is the almost hypnotic-like effect is has on people physically, to the point where stories, fables, books, movies, songs, etc. have been created and retold about it for as long as it has existed. Like many others, one of the main objections I hear about bitcoin is that it is "not real." No one EVER says that about gold, because it would be nonsensical. While I completely agree that bitcoin is the most perfect money ever created and am a hodler of it, I have to wonder in the context of your excellent article how the lack of a desirable physical presence in the world has effected/is effecting/will effect bitcoin in the future.

Jesse Myers's avatar

A thoughtful comment, much appreciated! I think most of the lore around gold and silver is the product of humanity coveting these assets for so long. As in, it's not the lore that makes them valuable - it's their scarcity. The lore is downstream of scarcity, a byproduct of scarcity dictating value.

I think 50 years from now it will be completely clear that Bitcoin is worlds better than gold and silver, and more valuable because of it. And that's all that really matters. The mythos will follow.

David Thornton's avatar

But Jesse isn't the reason humans covet them because of the effect they have on their physical senses? Isn't that how we perceive these materials? And if we cover them and the lore grows from the coveting because of the effects the materials have on our physical senses, how will bitcoin compare since there is no physical perception of bitcoin?

Russ Jacobsen's avatar

I loved this juxtaposing of ancient man with modern money/BTC. Great read.

Cory Hofmann's avatar

Amazing article. It goes beyond 'why didn't I think of that?' to 'why hasn't ANYONE thought of that?!'

Annah's avatar

I found this through Danny Knowles' podcast. This is an outstanding piece. Mindblowing. Ill need to come back to read a couple of times. Ive only just discovered Bitcoin (literally 9 weeks ago) and Ive been so obsessive about it that Im exhausted. Im not sure the obsession is healthy. I was hoping the learning curve would level out a bit and that I could get back to a normal pace of brain activity again. I was getting a bit over the whole price prediction click bait hype and the high hurdle to translate techno jargon. Was thinking I need to implement a self-imposed cold turkey on Bitcoin content for a while.

Nope. This article put an end to that hope 🤣 Hello new rabbit hole! TKTL1 explains why I'm obsessive about Bitcoin. If your thesis is correct Jesse then I'm just behaving like a true descendent of our common Mother Eve.

Please keep us up to date about whether you get in touch with Nick Szabo.

inertia's avatar

While people will understand what you mean by "close proximity," and it's quite common in everyday speech, it's considered redundant in careful or formal writing because "proximity" already means "close." Using just "proximity" or rephrasing with "close to" or "near" is more concise and precise.

Jesse Myers's avatar

Looked it up and it seems you are right - I was not aware that this was technically redundant. However, it is certainly the normative colloquial use, so I think I will (now) knowingly keep it in the redundant form. Elsewhere I do use the phrase "we're kinda weirdos" so I've made some deliberate choices for broad appeal and readability :)

Chris Krause's avatar

This is extraordinary!